|
Anesthesia, God and human pain |
|
|
"The heavens
manifest the
glory of
God, and the
firmament
the work of
His hands."
(Psalm 19)
The Nazis
invaded
Austria in
1938. They
arrested the
physician in
September
1942. Viktor
Frankl had
an office of
Neurology
and
Psychiatry
in Vienna.
Only on
April 27,
1945, he was
released by
the US
troops.
In prison he
experienced
strenuous
suffering.
He passed
through the
concentration
camps of
Auschwitz,
Kaufering
and
Türkheim. He
worked in
excavations,
tunnels and
railroad
constructions.
In his "off"
hours, he
did
psychological
analysis of
prisoners
and jailers
and wrote a
book, which
was
destroyed by
the invader.
In freedom,
he learned
that his
sister
Stella had
survived,
but that his
wife had
died in
Auschwitz at
the age of
only 24.
Soon after,
he wrote his
book In
Search of
Sense.
The
non-religious
human being
can adapt
and survive
in
"unbearable"
living
conditions.
Today we are
still
discussing
the reasons
for the
resistance
of these
"brilliant
minds" and
the
advantages
of a
reasoned
faith.
Allan Kardec
presents God
to us as the
scientists
present
themselves,
through
their Curriculum
Vitae.
From this
perspective,
by looking
under a
microscope /
telescope,
God gains
resourcefulness
and turns
away from
human
defects.
"The Supreme
Intelligence
created us
in its
likeness and
we pay in
the same
currency".
In Science
we filter
variables to
arrive at
the most
probable
hypothesis,
the one that
best
explains the
phenomenon.
In order to
distinguish
the origin
of suffering
we must
include the
"absurdity
hypothesis"
and to offer
the
possibility
of personal
choice and
free will.
Thus the
individual,
after the
due lawsuit,
ample
defense and
judgment, in
the court of
conscience,
would choose
the nature
of
suffering.
The
following
two examples
were
collected
through
mediumistic
practice.
The first
was of a
blind man
who asked
for the
medication
of the
shade, to
heal ancient
follies of
vision; the
second was
the prayer
of the
Spirit who
reincarnated
and became a
leper,
begging from
Heaven for
the garment
of wounds,
as a
purifying
remedy for
the
transgressed
personality
of the true
goodness. On
these laws
and severe
penalties,
the Encoder
of the
Spiritist
Doctrine
asked
question 796
of The
Book of
Spirits.
Is not the
severity of
criminal
laws a
necessity in
the present
state of
society?
"Understanding
suffering is
associated
with the
evolution of
humanity
itself, as
well as the
personal
conception
of God”. We
are
considering
the
examination
of evolution
through
anthropological
technique.
The cultural
development
of humanity,
in its
thinking,
feeling and
acting.
Its cultural
horizon is
characterized
by the
physical and
social
environment
in which a
phase of the
human psyche
occurred. In
the stage of
primitive
man, where
there was no
notion of
nature
itself,
could he not
think of the
"who am I"?
"What I am
doing here
and now". In
this phase
we will find
a God in the
"third age",
with white
hair. To
respect the
being, the
embryo, is
not yet of
this moment.
Even more
evolved, the
civilized
man will
still make
confusion
between the
human and
the divine,
merging
Religion and
the State.
There is the
construction
of
theological
empires. We
go through
the phase of
dogmas,
autocracy
and
religious
dictatorship.
Intolerance
and
oppression
of the State
are present.
The phase of
reason, the
scientific
man, and the
political-religious
opening
emerge in
man. From
that point
on, an
evolutionary
acceleration
phase seems
to occur.
Revelation
falls as the
only way to
gain
knowledge
about
nature.
Despite all
political-religious
oppression
and
intolerance,
man acquires
the ability
to formulate
abstract
concepts,
ethical
judgments
and legal
principles. Faith
is forced to
face reason.
With
Galileo, the
scientific
method
arises.
After 1800
revolutions
emerge like
the
industrial
one, where
the muscles
are replaced
by the
machines,
there is the
mastery of
the
techniques
and the
discovery of
the
electricity.
In a second
industrial
revolution
the brain is
replaced by
the
computer. We
are in
possession
of new
knowledge in
Biology,
such as DNA;
in physics,
like nuclear
energy.
In the 2000s
we find the
Information
revolution.
The age of
knowledge
arises to
magnify
admirable
achievements.
There are
the
Robotics,
Biotechnology,
Astrophysics
and
Internet.
However, man
continues to
face the
challenges
of economic,
social and
moral,
without the
support of
the
education of
feelings,
and there is
an imbalance
between
thinking,
feeling and
acting.
Today there
is an
imperative
need for
self-knowledge,
because the
mind that
was able to
do almost
everything,
could not
know itself.
The
information
revolution
brings us
the reality
of the
immortality
of the soul
and
reincarnation;
it brings
the notion
of a God,
Righteous
and Good.
We can see
that the
greater the
intelligences,
cognitive,
emotional
and
spiritual,
the greater
the distance
between the
God of the
universes
and the one
made in the
human image.
With Viktor
Frankl we
can say that
to find the
meaning of
life and
suffering it
is not
necessary to
acquire the
certainty of
the “fado”
singer: "it
was God who
gave light
to the eyes,
perfumed the
roses, and
gave gold to
the sun and
silver in
the
moonlight.
It was He
who put the
stars in the
sky, made
the endless
space,
mourned the
swallows,
made the
nightingale
poet and
gave the
flowers to
spring".
Even without
God we can
face pain in
the soul,
but
everything
becomes
easier when
we know that
"it was God
who gave
voice to the
wind." We
emphasize
that to live
in
conditions
of suffering
is to find
meaning in
pain.
Viktor
Frankl says
that when
all the
goals of
life are
broken, man
has only one
freedom: the
ability to
choose the
personal
attitude he
will assume
in the
circumstances
that
surround
him. He can
also
exemplify
the human
capacity to
rise above
its fate,
however
adverse it
may be and
to build a
dignified
and
honorable
life. This
life gives
meaning and
contributes
to the
benefit of
other lives.
The
immediatists
and/or
materialists
may
disagree. In
the book Reliquary
of Light,
in the
Decalogue of
the
Spiritual
Service, we
find the
recommendation
of the
Spirit Andre
Luiz: "If
you expect
noble
fulfillment,
do not
forget
unceasing
work,
persistence
in goodness,
edifying
study,
beneficent
sowing and
detached
service to
others".
Viktor did
incessant
work, even
in the
concentration
camps, and
did not
forget the
persistence
in the good.
Before being
arrested, he
refused to
carry out
euthanasia,
imposed by
the
oppressors
on "his"
mental
patients.
"We often
wonder how
there can be
materialists
when, having
passed
through the
spiritual
world, they
should have
intuition
from this
world: now
it is
precisely
this
intuition
that is
refused to
some Spirits
who,
retaining
pride, did
not repent
of their
faults. For
such men,
the proof
consists in
the
acquisition,
during
bodily life
and at the
expense of
their own
reasoning,
of the proof
of the
existence of
God and of
the future
life which
they have,
so to speak,
ceaselessly
under their
eyes. They
suffer the
penalty
until, when
their pride
is tamed,
they
surrender to
the
evidence".
Between
Heaven and
Earth,
events are
difficult to
explain. It
seems
impossible
to
understand
the designs
of God using
the limited
possibilities
of the human
mind. It is
as if the
mind could
not contain
in its glass
the water of
the ocean,
as the tiny
magical seed
retains
genetic
information.
Yet hope
remains,
when,
overcoming
pride, the
human mind
perceives
the
existence of
the tree.
Before the
pains
religious
and/or
spiritual
people seem
to have
benefits,
such as Leda
Amaral,
Jeronimo
Mendonca and
Marcondinho.
Leda - after
losing her
sight and
sensitivity
in the
fingers
caused by
the
"Leprosy" -
read in
Braille,
with the tip
of the
tongue.
Jeronimo
Mendonca was
a giant
lying down.
Marcondinho,
who when
incarnated
was blind
and had his
upper and
lower limbs
atrophied,
now as a
Spirit
rolled by
the TV
studio, to
demonstrate
the
immortality
of the soul
through the
mediumship
of the
interviewee
himself.
Another
example,
such as that
of Viktor
Frankl, is
that of the
man who saw
executioners
shoot his
family, and
yet made an
option for
love.
His
explanation
deserves
reflection: "I
begged to
die with my
family, but
because I
spoke German
they put me
in a work
group. I was
a lawyer; my
profession
had often
shown me
what hatred
could do to
people’s
bodies and
minds. My
eyes saw
what no one
should
witness. So
I made the
choice for
love, to
everything
and everyone
that I came
across in
life..."
Would
scientific
research
find
anesthesia
if God
desired
pain? How to
explain
spirituality
influencing
the
development
of
resilience?
Further
Reading:
1. "An
Atheist",
from Heaven
and Hell,
Part 2
Examples -
Chapter V.
Suicides.
Page 312,
33rd
edition.
From the 233 to
252
thousand.
Translation
by Manuel J.
Quintao.
1985.
2. Was I, by
any chance,
a Spirit? - click
here1
3. Drugs,
mediumship,
intelligences
and Chico
Xavier - click
here2
4.
Everything
goes - click
here3
5. Suicide
- click4
6. Leda
Amaral. At
the tip of
the tongue
- click5
7. Jeronimo
Mendonca - click
here6
8.
Marcondinho.
Heaven -
private
property - click
here7
Translation:
Eleni
Frangatos - eleni.moreira@uol.com.br