data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f0fce/f0fceb0d21f66356aafbee2d476c7dae2a8a2de5" alt="" |
André Luiz
Alves Jr. |
|
Jesus Christ,
myth or reality?
|
I often come
across some
readers
questioning
about the
existence of
Jesus. "There is
no concrete
evidence
regarding the
passage of the
Nazarene on
earth", some
claim. For some,
Christ is not a
historical
figure, but a
mythological
figure created
sometime in the
past.
The topic
instigates
heated
discussions and
deserves further
study, given
that such
questions
challenges
almost a third
of the world's
population (2
billion
Christians) and
also the history
of mankind.
The Emergence of
a Mythological
Christ -
Jesus was never
unanimity and
this fact is not
news to anyone.
Since the
beginning of his
preaching He
encountered
vehement
opponents.
Insofar as his
ministry grew,
the attacks of
antagonists
became
increasingly
violent,
resulting in his
arrest and
crucifixion.
Even after the
suffering of
Jesus on
Calvary,
Christian
persecution
continued,
however not
always in a
violent form.
Some hundreds of
Christians were
martyred in
Roman circuses,
others ridiculed
by intellectuals
who were trying
to discourage
Christianity.
The more
intelligent
people spread
the idea that
Jesus was a
mythological,
that is, he
never existed.
But despite the
contrary
efforts, the
Christian
movement
resisted and
became
perpetuated.
Almost two
millennia had
passed, and by
the year 1790,
in the era of
the French
Enlightenment,
thinkers such as
Constantine
François Volney
and Charles
François Dupuis
resurrected the
idea that Jesus
had been
created. These
opinions were
known as the
"Myth of Christ”
or “Mythical
Jesus “(the
inexistence of
Jesus).
The rationalist
Enlightenment
was a cultural
movement created
in order to
reform the
knowledge
inherited from
the medieval
tradition. This
knowledge,
hitherto, was
dictated by
imperious Roman
Church, hence
the emergence of
the theory of
the Myth of
Christ. It was a
way to confront
reasoning and
faith.
Mythical Jesus
did not spread
as thought by
the rational
Enlightenment
followers, the
religiosity of
the great mass
was much bigger.
Despite not
gaining
strength, the
theory is still
a controversy
raised by
sceptics in the
modern era. In
2002, the
Italian Luigi
Cascioli sued
the church for
believing that
institution fed
the lie of the
existence of
Jesus. The
lawsuit, after
going through
all instances,
was shelved for
lack of
evidence.
Confronting the
anti-Christian
ideas -
The first
argument is of a
sceptic is that
there is no
concrete
evidence of the
life of the
Nazarene. "Jesus
did not leave a
single sentence
written, no
archaeological
and documentary
evidence that
traces his life
and his
apostolate" some
claim.
To put things in
this light, we
will see that
Socrates, for
example, also
had not
documented his
ideas, but by no
means he ceased
to be one of the
largest and
best-known
philosophers of
antiquity,
because his
thoughts were
recorded and
broadcast by his
disciples, among
them, Plato.
Just as happened
with Jesus and
his apostles.
Let's look at
the other
questions raised
by
non-Christians:
1) Bible
Stories:
The more
religious people
would rebut the
criticism
concerning Jesus
referencing the
New Testament,
however, for the
opponents of the
Nazarene, the
Bible is not an
acceptable
historical
record. The
rationale would
be that the four
canonical
gospels have
been formulated
long after the
crucifixion of
the Saviour. In
addition, two of
the evangelists
(Luke and Mark)
did not even get
to know the
Carpenter of
Nazareth, so
their writings
are based on
reports from
third parties.
Another
important aspect
of the
anti-Christian
point of view is
that the
original scrolls
were edited
several times by
the church,
until the
current format,
besides being
copied and
translated into
other languages,
which can
significantly
misrepresent the
essence of
texts.
In fact, there
are
contradictions
between the
Gospels of the
New Testament;
however, the
existence of
Jesus is a
consensus among
them, including
the apocryphal
gospels (which
are not in the
Bible). Many
scholars believe
that less than
20 percent of
what we read in
the Gospels is
the original
sayings of the
Messiah. Not
even the most
incredulous
researchers
refute the idea
of the "Son of
God" to be a
historical
figure.
2) Roman
Conspiracy:
For some
theologians, the
creation of the
story of Jesus
would have been
a political
strategy of the
Romans to pacify
the violent
attacks of the
Jews who lived
in Palestine of
the time. This
argument is
contradictory as
Roman society
was polytheistic
and socially
segregated. The
Nazarene
personality (who
advocated a
single merciful
God and equality
among men)
differs from the
religious and
social beliefs
of that
civilization.
The Gods of
Roman mythology
were moody and
would never
accept a
patrician be
compared to a
slave.
3) The
construction of
the myth by
early
Christians:
Another argument
raised is that
the Jesus Myth
was created by
pioneers
Christians.
Could a group of
modest workers
devise a
grandiose
personality like
Jesus? And how a
myth would have
crossed
historical
periods without
being forgotten?
It
is unlikely that
much of humanity
would live all
this time
believing in an
allegorical
figure. If Jesus
did not exist,
one must imagine
how a myth could
alter so much
the history of
mankind.
Historical
evidence about
Jesus -
Before anything
else, it is
necessary to
answer the
following
question: What
distinguishes a
mythological
figure of a
historical
figure? In
order for
historians to
prove the
existence of a
historical
character, it is
necessary to
search for three
primary reasons:
documents of
ancient
historians,
historical
impact, and
other historical
documents and
archaeological
evidence.
Admittedly,
these gaps are
entirely
fulfilled by
Christ.
Historians
documents:
The first
historical
document we
present is
titled "Jewish
Antiquities,"
from the year 93
AD, written by
the historian
Josephus, born a
few years after
the crucifixion
of Jesus:
"Jesus lived
at that time, a
holy man, if he
can be called a
man, because he
did mighty
works, taught
men, and
received the
truth with
pleasure. And he
was followed by
many Jews and
many Greeks
[...] " 2
For modern
historians,
Flavius Josephus
is considered an
important
reference on the
history of Jesus
for he was a
scholar, who is
considered
impartial, ie,
he did not
belong to the
Christian
movement, which
evidences the
existence of the
historical
Christ.
Another
referenced
author is the
Roman historian
Gaius Suetonius
Tranquil. This
also has great
credibility due
to his
biographies on
the twelve Roman
emperors, from
Julius Caesar to
Domitian.
The work called
De Vita
Caesarum,
probably written
during the
period of
Hadrian, makes
mention of
Christians:
"Nero inflicted
punishment to
Christians, a
group of people
leaned towards a
new and evil
superstition."(Gaius
Suetonius
Tranquil - De
Vita Caesarum)
": Last but not
least, we find
Cornelius
Tacitus, born 25
years before
Jesus'
crucifixion and
also cites the
envoy of God in
his last
historical work
entitled
"Annals":
"Christus, which
gave rise to the
Christian name,
was sentenced to
extreme
punishment [ie
crucifixion] by
Pontius Pilate
during the reign
of Tiberius, but
repressed for a
time; the
pernicious
superstition
broke out again,
not only
throughout
Judea, where the
problem started,
but also in the
entire city of
Rome.”(Cornelius
Tacitus -
Annals)
Besides these
mentioned
historians there
is confirmation
of at least 19
ancient secular
writers who have
referred to
Jesus as a real
person. The
sources that
allude to the
Messiah are
numerous. There
are more books
about Him than
any other
historical
figure, which
would be
impossible for a
mythological
figure.
Historical
Impact:
It is clear the
impact that
Nazarene
personality
caused in human
history. We
could list a
hundred of them,
starting with
the Western
calendar, which
is counted from
his birth on
earth. Our time
is divided into
BC (BC) and
after Christ
(AD), this fact
alone is
self-explanatory.
Other evidences:
Several experts
in history (and
who have not
communicated
with each other)
use the same
sources to
affirm that that
Jesus is a real
figure. Scholars
defend that the
Messiah was, at
worst, a Jewish
preacher from
Galilee. Amongst
the sceptics, He
was seen as a
charismatic
healer, a
philosopher, or
an egalitarian
reformist. These
arguments
converge with
the ideas of
non-Christian
religions, among
which are
Judaism, the
main religion at
the time of
Jesus.
Mainstream
Judaism rejects
the proposal of
Jesus to be the
Messiah, because
he neither
performed the
Messianic
prophecies of
the "Tanach" nor
presents the
personal
qualifications
of the Messiah,
which does not
contradict its
existence. Jews
recognize Jesus
in a good Jew,
who passed
forward the
religious, moral
and ethical
teachings
received from
Judaism. Another
important
religious
doctrine in the
region of
pilgrimage of
Christ is Islam.
Islam considers
Jesus a
messenger of God
and the Messiah
sent to guide
the tribes of
Israel through
the new
scriptures, the
Gospel. The
belief in
Nazareth, and in
all other
messengers of
God, is part of
the requirements
for being a
Muslim. The
Koran mentions
the name of
Jesus
twenty-five
times, more than
Mohammed
himself, and
also emphasizes
that Jesus was a
mortal human
being who, like
all other
prophets, was
divinely chosen
to spread God's
message.
The extensive
documentation of
the life of
Jesus by writers
of the time, its
profound
historical
impact and
tangible and
confirming
evidence of
history
persuaded
scholars that
Jesus actually
existed.
Jesus for
Spiritism -
Many spiritist
works depicting
the life of
Christ and his
extraordinary
legacy, starting
with the coding
books.
References
depart own
spirituality:
625. What is the
most perfect
type that God
has offered to
man as his guide
and model?
"Jesus."
Jesus is the
type of the
moral perfection
to which man may
attain upon this
earth. God
offers Him to
our thought as
our most perfect
model and the
doctrine taught
by Him is the
purest
expression of
the divine law,
because He was
animated by the
divine spirit,
and was the
purest being who
has ever
appeared upon
the earth.
(The Spirits’
Book – Allan
Kardec)
To the Spiritist
Doctrine, Jesus
is the model and
guide, the more
evolved Spirit
that the Creator
sent to Earth to
serve as a
reference to
imperfect men,
as shown in the
above excerpt,
taken from the
basic work of
Spiritism.
Another booklet
that highlights
the existence of
Jesus as a
historical
figure emerged
through the
psychographics
of the Brazilian
medium Chico
Xavier. The book
"Two Thousand
Years" by the
spirit author
Emmanuel, tells
the story of one
of the spirit
author’s
reincarnations,
when he lived as
a Roman Senator
in the times of
Jesus. Publius
Cornelius
Lentulus is the
author of the
famous letter to
Caesar depicting
the figure of
Jesus. Maybe
this is the only
documented
reference of the
face of Christ.
Emmanuel still
offers the world
another book
rich in
historical
details about
Jesus. "Paul and
Stephen" is a
narrative of the
life of Saul of
Tarsus, a judge
of the Sanhedrin
who persecuted
Christians and
that, after a
vision of Jesus
at the gates of
Damascus, became
converted the
doctrine of
Christ, changing
the name to Paul
of Tarsus and
becoming one of
the greatest
apostles of
Christianity.
Paul, after his
conversion,
developed an
outstanding job,
taking the word
of Jesus to
communities that
did not yet know
the Master. He
founded churches
and wrote his
famous epistles.
Some historians
argue that his
letters were the
first produced
records
referencing the
life of the
Carpenter of
Nazareth.
The converted
one from
Damascus did not
know Jesus
personally, but
became very
close to Simon
Peter and the
other apostles
who provided
notes and
important data
about Him. At
least six of the
thirteen
epistles
attributed to
Paul had its
authenticity
proven by
historians,
which refers to
the truthfulness
of a Historical
Jesus.
To Spiritism
there is no
doubt that Jesus
was a real
person, who
lived on earth
to show with his
examples, the
path to moral
progress. The
contrary
opinions
constitute
differences of
the
individuality of
each spirit, but
sooner or later
the sceptics
will recognize
its importance
as Emmanuel
recognized:
[...]
You find, today,
a reference
point for the
regeneration of
all your life.
It is, however,
in your wantting
to enjoy it now
or in a few
millennia.
(Jesus speaking
with Publius
Lentulus, the
book “Two
thousands years
ago”, channelled
by psychography
by medium Chico
Xavier)
References:
1. Annals -
Cornelius
Tacitus
2. Jewish
Antiquities
3. The Research
for the
Historical Jesus
4. The Spiritis’
Book - Allan
Kardec
5. Two Thousands
Years Ago –
channelled by
Chico Xavier,
authorship of
the spirit
Emmanuel
6. Paul and
Stephen -
channelled by
Chico Xavier,
authorship of
the spirit
Emmanuel
|